Property Passed In at Auction NSW: What Happens Next and How Buyers Can Negotiate

Property Passed In at Auction NSW? What Buyers Should Do Next

Watch this video on YouTube.

You have spent weeks inspecting a property, reviewing the contract and preparing for auction day.

The bidding starts.

The price climbs.

Then suddenly the auctioneer announces:

“The property is passed in.”

So what happens now?

For buyers, a property being passed in at auction can create one of the most important negotiation opportunities in the entire purchasing process.

But it can also create pressure.

The selling agent may immediately try to move negotiations forward, the vendor may still have a higher price expectation, and other buyers may still be interested.

Understanding what “passed in” actually means can help you decide whether to negotiate, increase your offer, hold your position or walk away.

What Does “Passed In” Mean at a NSW Property Auction?

Before a property auction in NSW, the vendor sets a reserve price.

This is generally the minimum price the vendor is prepared to accept at the auction.

If bidding does not reach the reserve price and the vendor does not agree to sell at a lower amount during the auction, the property may be passed in.

The property has therefore not been sold at auction.

NSW Government guidance states that when a property is passed in because bidding has not met the reserve, the highest bidder will generally have the first opportunity to negotiate with the seller.

Does the Highest Bidder Automatically Buy the Property?

No.

Being the highest bidder on a property that is passed in does not mean you have purchased it.

For example:

The highest genuine bid may be:

$1,450,000

But the vendor’s reserve may be:

$1,500,000

If the vendor does not agree to sell for $1.45 million, the property can be passed in.

The highest bidder will generally be given the first opportunity to negotiate, but there is still a gap between what the buyer is prepared to pay and what the vendor wants.

That is where the negotiation begins.

What Happens Immediately After the Auction?

The selling agent will often approach the highest bidder and try to continue negotiations.

They may say something such as:

“The vendor wants $1.5 million. Can you improve your offer?”

Or:

“If you can get closer to the reserve, I think we can put a deal together.”

This is where buyers need to remain disciplined.

The auction may have finished, but the negotiation has not.

The vendor can negotiate with interested buyers or return the property to the market if an agreement cannot be reached.

The Reserve Price Is Not Automatically the Property’s Market Value

This is an important distinction.

The reserve price represents what the vendor is prepared to accept at that particular auction.

It does not automatically prove that the property is worth that amount.

Suppose:

• Comparable sales indicate approximately $1.42m–$1.47m
• Bidding stops at $1.445m
• The vendor wants $1.52m

The fact that the vendor wants another $75,000 does not automatically mean the buyer should pay it.

You still need to consider:

• recent comparable sales
• land size
• condition
• location
• street quality
• renovation requirements
• property-specific risks
• competing buyer demand
• your finance position
• what the property is actually worth to you

The vendor’s expectations are part of the negotiation — not your valuation method.

Don’t Automatically Meet the Reserve Price

This is where buyers can accidentally negotiate against themselves.

Imagine the bidding stops at:

$1,460,000

The agent tells you:

“The reserve is $1.5 million.”

You immediately say:

“Okay, I’ll pay $1.5 million.”

You have just increased your offer by $40,000.

But was that necessary?

Perhaps the vendor would have accepted:

$1,475,000

or

$1,485,000

You don’t necessarily know.

A better approach is to make deliberate movements rather than immediately jumping to the vendor’s requested price.

Ask Yourself What Has Actually Changed

This follows the same principle as a “best and final offer”.

Ask:

Has anything happened that changes what I believe the property is worth?

The auction gives you additional information.

You now know something about how other registered buyers behaved at that particular auction.

But you still shouldn’t allow the emotion of auction day to completely replace your assessment of the property.

Know Your Maximum Before You Negotiate

One of the best ways to avoid emotional decisions is to establish your maximum price before auction day.

For example:

Estimated property value:

$1.45m–$1.50m

Your absolute maximum:

$1.485m

Auction passes in at:

$1.455m

The vendor wants:

$1.52m

You now have a framework for your negotiation.

Without a predetermined limit, it’s easy for:

$1.455m

to become:

$1.47m

then:

$1.48m

then:

$1.49m

and eventually:

“It’s only another $10,000.”

That is how buyers can end up paying considerably more than they originally intended.

You Don’t Have to Reveal Your Maximum

Suppose your maximum is $1.485 million.

That does not mean your first post-auction offer needs to be:

$1,485,000.

You may decide to negotiate toward that figure depending on the circumstances.

There is a major difference between:

knowing your maximum

and

telling the selling agent your maximum.

Your limit is primarily for your own decision-making.

Small Price Movements Can Matter

The selling agent may encourage larger increases:

“Can you come up another $20,000?”

But you are not required to negotiate in the increments suggested by the agent.

Depending on the circumstances, a buyer might decide to move:

$2,500

$5,000

or another amount they consider appropriate.

The size and timing of your movements can form part of the negotiation.

The important thing is that each increase should be deliberate rather than driven purely by pressure.

Can Other Buyers Still Negotiate?

Potentially, yes.

A passed-in property has not automatically been sold simply because one buyer was the highest bidder.

The highest bidder generally gets the first opportunity to negotiate, but until contracts are exchanged, buyers should not assume the property is secured.

NSW Government guidance also makes clear that buyers and sellers are not legally bound simply because an offer has been discussed or accepted — exchange of contracts is the critical point. (NSW Government)

That means taking too long can carry risk as well.

You need to balance:

not being pressured into overpaying

against

being prepared to act when the price and terms make sense.

Negotiate More Than Just the Purchase Price

Price is obviously important, but it isn’t necessarily the only thing that matters to a vendor.

Depending on the circumstances, buyers may also discuss:

• settlement period
• deposit arrangements
• inclusions
• requested contract amendments
• timing of exchange
• other conditions

Never agree to changes you don’t understand simply to make your offer look stronger.

Your solicitor or licensed conveyancer should advise you regarding the contract and legal implications.

Put Your Offer Clearly in Writing

Once negotiations become serious, putting your offer in writing can help create a clear record.

For example:

Purchase price: $1,480,000
Deposit: As agreed under the contract
Settlement: 42 days
Other terms: Subject to agreed contract amendments

NSW Government also recommends that buyers obtain the sale contract, have it reviewed by a solicitor or conveyancer, have finance arranged and consider putting offers in writing. (NSW Government)

Be Careful About Cooling-Off Rights After a Passed-In Auction

This is particularly important in NSW.

There is no cooling-off period if contracts are exchanged on the same day as the auction after the property has been passed in. (NSW Government)

That can make post-auction negotiations very different from an ordinary private-treaty purchase.

If contracts are exchanged later, different cooling-off rules may apply depending on the circumstances, and a cooling-off period can also be waived using a 66W certificate.

Get advice from your solicitor or licensed conveyancer before agreeing to exchange.

What If You Can’t Agree With the Vendor?

You can walk away.

That can be difficult after spending weeks researching a property and attending the auction.

But there is no requirement to bridge the gap simply because you’ve already invested time and emotion into the property.

Suppose your maximum is:

$1.485m

The vendor refuses anything below:

$1.525m

You have a decision to make.

Not:

“How do I find another $40,000?”

But:

“Does the evidence justify changing my maximum?”

If the answer is no, walking away may be the better deal.

There will be other properties.

What If the Agent Calls You Later?

This happens.

The vendor may initially refuse your offer.

Several hours later — or sometimes in the following days — the selling agent may contact interested buyers again.

The vendor’s expectations may have changed.

But don’t assume that automatically means you should increase your previous offer.

Reassess the situation based on:

• your previous offer
• any new information
• whether other genuine buyers remain interested
• the vendor’s revised expectations
• comparable sales
• your original maximum

Sometimes patience can strengthen your negotiating position.

Other times another buyer may secure the property.

There is no single tactic that works in every negotiation.

Example: A Property Passes In at $1.6 Million

Imagine a Sydney home passes in with you as the highest bidder at:

$1,600,000

The agent tells you the reserve is:

$1,675,000

You have already assessed comparable properties and determined your maximum at:

$1,640,000

Instead of jumping straight to $1.64 million, you might decide to continue negotiating in controlled increments.

The vendor may reduce their expectations.

You may increase.

Eventually you could meet somewhere in between.

Or the vendor may refuse to move sufficiently.

At that point, your maximum gives you something extremely valuable:

the ability to walk away without making an emotional decision.

Why Passed-In Auctions Can Create Opportunities for Buyers

A passed-in auction tells both sides something.

The vendor has just tested the property publicly.

The buyer has seen where bidding stopped.

The agent has seen how much genuine competition was present.

That information can change the negotiation dynamic.

But it doesn’t automatically mean the property is a bargain.

And it doesn’t automatically mean the vendor must accept the highest bid.

It simply creates a new negotiation.

How a Sydney Buyer’s Agent Can Help After a Property Is Passed In

Post-auction negotiations can move quickly.

A buyer’s agent can assist by helping a buyer:

• assess comparable sales
• understand the property’s value
• establish a maximum purchase price
• communicate with the selling agent
• structure negotiation movements
• remain disciplined under pressure
• identify property-specific concerns
• coordinate with the buyer’s solicitor, conveyancer and finance professionals
• negotiate on the buyer’s behalf

The objective isn’t simply to buy the property at any cost.

It’s to help determine whether the property makes sense at the price required to secure it.

Sometimes buying is the right decision.

Sometimes walking away is the better deal.

Buying at Auction in Sydney?

If you’re actively inspecting properties, attending auctions or negotiating with selling agents, having someone representing your side of the transaction can help you make more informed decisions.

Truth Group provides professional buyer representation across Sydney, including property search, assessment, due diligence, negotiation and auction support.

Explore Sydney Buyer’s Agent Services

View Buyer’s Agent Fees

Discuss My Property Search

Full-service residential buyer representation starts from $9,500 + GST for purchases up to $1.5 million.

Final Thoughts

A property being passed in at auction does not mean the opportunity is over.

In many cases, the real negotiation is only beginning.

The highest bidder will generally have the first opportunity to negotiate with the vendor, but that doesn’t mean the buyer should immediately agree to the reserve price.

Know what the property is worth.

Know your maximum.

Understand the contract.

Keep your negotiation deliberate.

And don’t allow the fear of missing out to turn a property you wanted into a property you overpaid for.

---

Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal, financial, credit or property advice. Auction and contract circumstances vary. Buyers should obtain advice from an appropriately qualified solicitor or licensed conveyancer regarding contracts, cooling-off periods, 66W certificates and other legal matters.

I fact-checked the NSW auction mechanics against the NSW Government’s Buying Property at an Auction guidance, updated 8 July 2026, and current NSW contract/offer guidance.